YUVAL SHAUL

A Tale of Mammals

Wei Xing
From the monograph Violence and Compassion, Ofer Levin Foundation for Israeli Art, 2018.

Black whale,
Breathing silently on the shore of earth,
It is a weapon of war, but also the spirit of nature,
The deer cruises in the center of a “World Island”,
Crossing borders and conquest are the constant rhythm of history.

If you look for Israel on the map, you will find that this country is located right in the middle of an area where the ancient Mesopotamian and Egyptian civilizations emerged five thousand years ago. And from there passing into the Mediterranean, heading to the northwest, you will arrive at Crete and the Greek mainland. To the northeast lies Jordan, and beyond that Iran, of ancient Persia. This land is the origin of many classical civilizations, defined as the “World Island’s” inner crescent region by British scholar Halford John Mackinder in his political geography of the early 20th century. The point of convergence and conflict of historical powers, this is a magical land. History, religion and civilization integrate and interact here, and then separate and oppose each other.

One day in August 2014, a friend drove me to a place called Jaffa which is adjacent to Tel Aviv to visit an artist. After leaving Tel Aviv’s modern downtown which was full of skyscrapers, in just 10 minutes’ drive we had arrived at this small ancient town bordering the Mediterranean. In fact, today it has been integrated into Tel Aviv, but still retains its own historical temperament and appearance. Jaffa was a thriving port city in ancient times which traded with Egypt, Crete and Asia Minor. According to my friend’s introduction, this city’s founding history can be traced back 5,000 years, making it probably one of the oldest cities in the world. Jaffa’s blocks are narrow, along the road there are many two or three-story buildings with rich Mediterranean features which are built with milky white or light khaki granite stones; many small shops, restaurants and cafes scattered among them, they look like the landscape on postcards against the background of palm trees and blue sea. We arrived at an old building which looked like an old warehouse. This was Israeli artist Yuval Shaul’s studio.

When you talk to Yuval, his deep blue-green eyes will stare at you firmly, as if he’s able to see into your heart. Yuval is very outgoing, cheerful and talkative, he seems to be very familiar with all people living in the city, including many artists, as well as various bars and nightclubs. Clearly he loves life very much, he always appears cool and casual wearing a confident expression on his face when we were talking to each other; only when it comes to his eldest son who served as a soldier in the Gaza Strip, his eyes reveal a trace of melancholy and worry, his speech becoming softer and slower. At such times, as a foreigner, I suddenly become aware of the various complexities, tangled history and reality of this country, in which everyone has been a soldier at one time.

We are sitting in Yuval’s spacious studio, drinking coffee, surrounded by a pile of photographs, paintings, bronze sculptures, small installations, and some animal specimens. I noticed that almost all his works are related to animals: A zebra whose whole head had fallen into a pillar; a half-human, half-horse beast holding bows and arrows; a deer with two heads in front and back; a group of life-size hunter silhouettes made of cattle and sheep fur; and imaginative reassembled world maps, etc. These works appear to have a surreal style, inadvertently showing some black humor. They seem to hint at themes of nomadism, migration, war, victory and defeat, life and death, and also touch some issues such as history, politics and society in a symbolic way.

In the center of his studio, there is a beast’s skull surrounded by some speakers. The Snow-white skull reflects on the glossy black mirror-like marble counter-top, unexpectedly presenting an extreme heart-stopping savage beauty. Yuval tells me that this work is called “Silence Is the Most Beloved Food of Sorrow”, it tells of the death of a tiger, the king of the forest. It is surrounded by six non-functioning speakers, as if only silence will comfort its sleeping soul. Next to this installation is a sketch for another work, a black whale that looks like a transformative submarine with a drain hole and tail propeller. It is about 18 meters (60 feet) long, and the technicians are now producing it in a factory and installing a beating heart in it. After inflating, it will become a jumbo and be placed in an empty space as a stranded machine whale that cannot go back to the blue sea. The loneliness and sadness expressed by this work in some way reflects the eternal human self-contradiction forever swinging back and forth between the nostalgic, nature-loving heart, and the desire to go far away, to conquer nature. The giant sub-whale is a symbol of the ghost of our time, wandering in a foreign land without being able to return home.

Time unknowingly slipped as we find ourselves engrossed in conversation, afternoon sunshine slanted on the wall of the studio. I stop worrying about the whale-submarine’s fate, and instead become attracted to a group of black and white pictures on the wall. They are made of a combination of stages photography, montage and digital processing. The images are of naval battle scenes: Smoke rising from a burning sunk battleship, gloomy fog enveloping the sea, while the faint shadow of a huge pair of antlers rises above the vessels. The huge antlers are growing out of the body of the battleships, as if they are made of flesh and bones which give these steel machines an animal’s emotions and soul. They line up in the vast ocean, like a group of stray animals prowling in the melancholic wasteland of history. They are an elusive magical phantom in the shadow, as if history’s nightmare, passing the barriers of times and space, is coming to us.

In Yuval’s opinion, the deer’s antlers symbolize masculine power, while the deer itself is extremely docile. These two opposite yet unified temperaments make this animal noble and elegant, and consequently the noble man’s favorite hunting target. All the old castles and palaces that appear in European films had deer head decorations hung in their halls. Hung on walnut panels, next to tapestry depicting a heroic knight killing a dragon and ancient masters’ portraits, they demonstrate the owner’s glory and pride, and his achievements as a brave hunter. In my eyes, this reflected a human obsession, a sin stemming from the desire to chase, possess and destroy something beautiful and noble, together with the satisfaction which one derives from conquest. Yuval has created a lot of works with this theme, installing towering antlers on the model of weapons and ships designed by him, endowing these cold metal sculptures and installations with a sense of life and body. The meaning and purpose of these works are not only to create a magical form and visual impact, but to introduce dual perspective from both human and animal points of view as well as to highlight the continuous conflicts and sacrifices caused by religious, cultural, ideological and ethnic issues since the beginning of human kind. Here the artist actually adopts a detached and objective standpoint – he not only criticizes the brutality and the horrors of war, but also laments human beings’ naïve romanticism and faith in the graceful through the use of the deer’s antler as a theme and symbol in his work, and links this lament with love for nature. In addition, Yuval’s work can be seen as reflecting the almost subconscious fear brought by the shadow of war that the people in this country have lived under since the establishment of the state of Israel.

Deer are mammals. One of the characteristics of mammals is a well-developed brain and nervous system, so they have the possibility of developing high intelligence. Some species possess emotion and self-awareness, and self-awareness implies the desire for possession and competition. Humans are the most developed of mammals, and thus humans enjoy the most sophisticated intelligence, as well as the strongest consciousness and self-awareness. In Eastern civilization there is also a tradition of using different animal images to correspond to different forces of nature and use these symbols on the national political level. There are a lot of records and descriptions of deer in Chinese historical records and literature, deer has become a highly symbolic animal in politics, the famous Chinese idiom “Chasing the Deer in the Middle Land” refers to the acquiring of supreme power in ancient China. The deer has therefore become a symbol that reflects the ideas of survival, battle, expansion and conquest. It is interesting to find that the works of Yuval Shaul resonate an ancient Chinese idiom.

Humans created civilization, and all civilizations were, without exception, born from bloodshed. Humans differentiate themselves from nature and stand opposite to nature. Humans believe that they are superior to animals, that they are the rulers and God of this planet. Following thousands of years of evolution and struggle, humans have created and destroyed countless large and small civilizations. Scholars and intellectuals have developed a large variety of theories of geopolitics that advanced national interests and political struggles. Yuval Shaul’s “World Map” series, which are remade of cow skin, placed the Yellow Sea adjacent to Africa` Asia connected with America, and Australia linked with the Arctic. Artistically, the work has deconstructed the British scholar Halford John Mackinder’s “World Island” theory that was released a century ago, rearranged and recombined various countries’ borders according to the artist’s utopian idea, thus breaking people’s inherent and fixed understanding of geography as well as cultural and ideological boundaries. Through these battleships with antlers and the stranded whale submarine, Yuval Shaul questions the stereotypical perceptions of reality and history.

We left Yuval’s studio at dusk, drove back to Tel Aviv and were about to have supper. In the downtown suddenly we heard the harsh air raid sirens, followed by some toneless explosions sounds not far from us. Yuval told me it was the explosion of a rocket from Gaza that was destroyed by the antimissile defense system “Iron Dome” in mid-air. This was my first time being so close to a small-scale war, it stimulated my almost numb nerves, urged me to re-look at this seemingly peaceful, constant, and materialistic world. I looked at Yuval Shaul’s calm face, realized that this country’s people have different feelings and understandings of life and death, and thus understood the mentality of creating that stranded but still breathing giant black sub-whale.

Friedrich Nietzsche once declared that “God is dead. I think he was not referring to the true demise of God, but to the human desire to overthrow, indeed to replace God. When I see Yuval Shaul’s works which are full of animal allegories, when I hear the deafening explosions of war, I think, that we are merely animals too, like those endangered tigers, whales and other creatures, trapped on this little blue planet. We live just as those happy people, satisfied but numb’ poor people that Aldous Huxley once described in his magnificent Brave New World, achieving their so-called great and glorious missions through illusion and hypnosis. This, in my opinion, is the significance of Yuval Shaul’s works: whether the huge antlered machine, or the submarine=like whale, they are just allegories pointing to the unpredictable future of mankind.

← Violent PassionForests Adrift, Forests of War →