YUVAL SHAUL

Patterns of Survival

Keren Goldberg in conversation with Yuval Shaul
From the monograph Violence and Compassion, Ofer Levin Foundation for Israeli Art, 2018.

Keren Goldberg: Your works have a fine, shiny, seductive finish. They are very beautiful.

Yuval Shaul: Throughout history beauty has always triumphed. When you look at Ancient Greek or Assyrian art, the art of the Renaissance, the Baroque, Rococo, the beauty is the first thing you see. Only afterwards you begin to notice hints Velasquez hid in his paintings, or Michelangelo’s distortions. History remembers symbols and beauty provides powerful, enduring ones. My works are about power.

KG: Power that must be handled knowledgeably.

YS: Power must be manipulated. My work strives for perfection and beauty especially when its subject matter is disconcerting. I seek to create things that are both attractive and repulsive. A taxidermied animal, a mount, is a somewhat disgusting object that evokes moral issues. The end product can be very beautiful and enticing. I am attracted to these kinds of sensations that are very far from any need for provocation. I have never wanted to work with blood or flesh or, for that matter, taxidermied humans. I like things encased in a beautiful exterior, a cultural plaster. The “want of matter” trend in local art never appealed to me. It was welcome in the 1970s when artists were testing the limits of art. Now it is irrelevant.

KG: Yet it is still prevalent today, in DIY aesthetics and the like.

YS: It is difficult for me to treat it as an aesthetic principle; something the local art world has criticized me for over the years. Eventually, we all want to be beautiful and are seduced by beauty. Beautiful things affect us positively and give us the illusion of control over our surroundings. In a world in which everything is supposedly allowed and given to interpretation only the sexual realm is secretive. It is where we hide and feel ashamed, where we can rebel and misbehave. I find the art realm similar. I like art that is unresolved, that confronts me with my assumptions, that allows me to surprise myself.

KG: Your work is very instinctive. Your use of text lends it certain rationality. How does the written word fit into your practice?

YS: I gave up writing very quickly because I felt it was being overused. I had begun using words in the cowhide atlases on which I printed the names of the continents (Map of the World, Africa Europe, 1990-1999). Referring to these works, Osvaldo Romberg once remarked that text is civilization’s imprint on nature. I used a font commonly found in 19th century atlases, which are of course products of colonialism and imperialism, to provoke questions about natural and manmade borders, names, power, subjugation, etc.

KG: The imperialistic ramifications are very pronounced. In the atlas works language functions as a marker, as opposed to the works with the phrases printed on the cowhide (No Justice, Just Us!, 1990-1999) in which something different occurs. The atlas sentences exude self-importance and gravity. However, you present them in a way that empties them of meaning, and makes them seem cynical and clichéd, as if the text itself is a representation of something.

YS: Although my works are not humorous they can be very cynical and clichéd. A cliché is really nothing but a glorified or overcooked ideal. I did something similar with the titles of the naval destroyers, aircraft carriers and submarine sculptures – Hope, Agony and Vow (Il nuovo mondo, 2004-2009). The cowhide of course symbolizes the victim, the prey. The moralistic sentences imprinted on it in a biblical font, such as “No justice, just us,” “The conscience is like a thousand witnesses,” or “Purify my heart but not yet,” emphasize the power dynamic and allows the viewer to identify with the implied violence.

KG: The second commandment, "Thou shalt not make unto thee any graven image" touches on the tension between visual images and words. In the text works that combine religious elements and sacrificial traditions language is transformed into image.

YS: The print revolution is usually understood in terms relating to the preservation and distribution of information. But something else also occurred when language became visual. What was formerly abstract, only sound, took on another form and involved the sense of sight. We take these things for granted and can easily recognize different languages. Yet in the old world, which was much less visual, one can imagine that the written word had a lot of power. Today, when I say “God” in Hebrew you visualize the Hebrew letter ה'. My work with language was at its peak when I translated a sentence from the national anthem - “Our hope is not yet lost, to be a free people in our land” – into Arabic and then printed it on the cowhide. I did the same with two fundamental Zionist phrases: “If you will it, it is no dream,” and “It is good to die for our country.” In Arabic these sentences sound threatening to us and immediately evoke an association with terror.

KG: That is the tragedy of nationalism.

YS: I agree. I was playing the innocent card, thinking how wonderful it is that we can share our history with another nation. Then I stopped. My work became too political, so I left it.

KG: Why do you shy away from politics?

YS: I think that good political art is not a form of propaganda. Velasquez, for example, did not use propaganda or the written word to get his message across. The way he staged the royal family and his use of perspective was enough. His Las Meninas still resonates with us because the painting is about human interaction and art’s ability to transform the private experience into something universal. The problem with identity or political art is mostly its lack of sophistication, finesse and edge.

KG: The series Judaica (2006-2013) has chalices and Kiddush cups; one even has the word Kiddush written on it. How do you feel toward them as religious symbols?

YS: Although I am a secular man and an atheist, I find much beauty in the Jewish tradition. My grandfather was very religious and lived in Jerusalem. We still do Kiddush every Friday evening at my mother’s. The Kiddush cup, like the other Havdala items, is a type of object that transcends the natural into the spiritual. The cup embodies the relation between Judaism and masculinity because these cups, which usually contained wine, belong to winners, warriors and knights. I read an article recently on the chemsex phenomenon among gay men – long parties that involve certain types of drugs and sex, and are often very wild and dangerous. It led me to think about the homoerotic realm as the ultimate form of masculinity – the type of uncontrolled, risky, hedonistic male existence – and that it is possible solely within the homosexual community. The ultimate male world could only exist in a homoerotic world, one devoid of women.

KG: Masculinity is not necessarily groundbreaking. Straight masculinity can be very structured, with many demands and expectations.

YS: Conventional heterosexual masculinity is based on codes of control. Monotheist patriarchal cultures glorify the male who controls the masses – the man who never shows his weaknesses. On the other hand, the world has advanced thanks to risk taking men – Alexander Macedon, Galileo, Marco Polo –who were willing to die in pursuit of their dreams.

KG: Your works also indicate tension between instinctive, materialistic, seductive beauty and the austerity and frugality of spiritual religion with its symbols and words.

YS: These conflicts have found their way into the Israeli-Zionist narrative. The early settlers that came to Palestine before the establishment of the state wished to form a new image of the Jew as a strong, land-working native (sabra). However, one characteristic associated with the figure of the diaspora Jew from which they sought to distance themselves, was sexual repression. The new, modern Jew was asexual, as was manifest in their clothing, their folkdances, etc. The immigrants from North Africa, who arrived in the country in the 1950s with their extroverted sexuality, revealing clothes and fancy grooming habits intimidated the pioneers and produced the type of slang that developed to describe them. The same thing occurred with the arrival of immigrants from the former Soviet Bloc in the late 1980s and 90s. As for the Kiddush cup, despite its feminine associations it is, first and foremost, a phallic symbol. I associated it with homoeroticism because it contains alcohol. The need to test boundaries, to lose control and to self-destruct is tied to masculinity and to alpha males.

KG: The hybrid images of the naval destroyers with deer antlers in Il nuovo mondo (2009) portray that duality of strength and vulnerability; of power as weakness.

YS: I see the deer as symbolizing modern masculinity. It is big and impressive, the king of the forest, but at the same time, an herbivore and a hunted animal. As such, I find that parody offers me an ideal tool, and I often use it to place an existing convention in a different, contrary, context. Not necessarily so as to mock conventions, but to create dialogue about existing social constructs. As to the works with the destroyers – weapons of massive power and strength, as evidenced by their name – I took photos of World War II destroyers and added to them a pair of deer antlers. This act attests to their power and endurance, but at the same time to their fragility and the fact that they, too, are hunted and pursued. This generates an internal dialogue between the viewer and the work. I did something similar with the letter openers, these innocent objects designed for the office desk, whose handles I designed from the phrase “Allahu akbar,” thus juxtaposing different aspects of the same object. I think this kind of dialogue is relevant in our reality and our masculinity discourse. Modern masculinity harbors an innate vulnerability. Capitalism, with its obsession with success, puts huge demands on men: to be active and involved fathers, sensitive husbands, successful breadwinners. That is not to say that women have it easy, but that men are experiences some sort of crisis. They are weak, and so they fight. A strong person does not need to fight. Those who are still fighting have yet to prove their power.

KG: Have you experienced this crisis in your private life?

YS: I am a father to two young men. My own father died many years ago. For most of my life I lacked financial security and this fact underlies my preoccupation with survival. The need to make sure there is money for food, rent, etc. became, at some point, animalistic. To survive, you need to exercise some cunning. At the same time you have to be human. Many times I imagined an apocalyptic reality and thought what I would do if I had nothing, how I would provide for my loved ones. I wonder if I have it in me to slaughter and eat my neighbor’s dog, or am I too much of a humanist.

KG: Do you think that is the reason, perhaps even on a subconscious level, that your work is commercially appealing?

YS: The commercial consideration began with the bronze statues that I use to finance the expensive taxidermy pieces which are not at all commercial. Undoubtedly, my interest in animals, hunting and masculinity comes from my involvement with the survival of modern men. This is why I insisted on slaughtering some of the animals myself. I love animals very much and all of my work addresses that compassion. I find it very strange that so few local artists treat the issue of manhood in their work.

KG: The international art scene as a whole is not really preoccupied with masculinity.

YS: After 1967, local art was chauvinistic and macho. That is no longer the case. Today art looks at masculinity from the viewpoint of gender issues, not male DNA. This may change, as a result of the crisis in masculinity. Ernst Hemingway was ahead of his time in that regard, with his very manly writing style seeped in self-destruction and stories about hunting and manhood. He committed suicide with the same rifle he used for hunting. I feel an affinity with the characters in his stories and with his personal biography. In the 1950s Marlon Brando also created his Hollywood star persona, a desirable, handsome man who is also weak, vulnerable and childish; conflicted with reality.

KG: I think that the preoccupation with the crisis of masculinity is seen in recent television series. The moralistic manly hero has transformed into an anti-hero, a family man who chooses to provide for his family in immoral ways. Going back to your life, what is the role of your own figure as a recurring theme in your work?

YS: I started to use my own figure in recent years simply because I needed a male figure. I never thought of putting myself as myself in my art, except for the image of me carrying myself (Double Self-Portrait, 2005) that came at a critical time in my life.

KG: You went on to use your figure in a number of different works.

YS: I began using my own figure more when my sons reached puberty. There comes a moment when your sons grow taller and become stronger than you. It has a very intense subconscious effect. On the one hand you are delighted to see your genetics enhanced, on the other, you come to realize that you are no longer young. The life-size piece with both my sons, Itay and Ohad, (No Justice, Just Us!, 2006) is made from one large cowhide. In retrospect there is something very symbolic in that – the cowhide center starts around the reproductive area. Both my sons are armed with weapons but I am not holding anything, just standing there. That is the moment of the painful realization that your sons are physically strong and you can rely on them. Looking back I realize how much this crisis seeped into my work. In a sense, the issue of masculinity in my work evolved similarly to a teenager’s sexual development. Whereas the body is physically ready, the emotions remain childish. Likewise my artistic progress – it took me a while to understand my interest in masculinity and to grow up. It happened when my sons came of age. At the time, when they saw the works and talked to me about manhood I did not see it. I do not work from ideas but from images. First I create, then I question. A good piece of art is always smarter than its creator. I often come across a wonderful piece, but when the artist who made it attempts to talk about it he or she cannot. This, of course, is not the case with Israeli artists. Here everyone is very opinionated.

KG: The fact that an artist cannot explain their work does not imply that he or she lacks intelligence.

YS: Of course not. I have a romantic view of an artist’s inability to explain his or her work; it reflects a pure and real place. After the work with my sons I wanted to do something with my daughter, Alona. I was inspired by the tragic biblical story about the daughter of Jephthah. I wanted to make an image of myself armed with guns, clubs and knives with Alona on my shoulders. Together, we would look like some alien figure. However, the whole thing became too theatrical and phantasmagorical. When I start to feel that my self-definition is based on the work and not the other way around, I leave it. When you know exactly how your next piece is going to look there is really no point in making it. I like to take something, exhaust it and start over. Somewhat tragically, art is a perpetual search. When you are good at doing something there is always the option of doing more of it, but that is not for me. I like to set things up and move on. I have never understood how artists can work solely in one medium.

KG: You can have a lot of innovation and development in any medium.

YS: Of course you can. Painting is the medium I always return to. It acts like a vacation from art. It is the only place in which I experience intimacy, a bit like therapy.

KG: Perhaps it is because you are alone when you paint, as opposed to your work in other media, which involves many people.

YS: Yes. In painting it is just me; one on one. It is like the difference between a meal with a group of friends and a cup of coffee alone while ruminating. I need these moments of privacy that painting provides. This is partly because my other works are mostly three-dimensional and entail long processes with various professionals, workshops, simulations, etc. I manage a lot of different people whom I instruct over the phone. It is a process I thoroughly enjoy. One thing I have always avoided is any attachment to the notion of a personal style. It is a romantic idea, but one I find archaic.

KG: But your work has a very distinctive style.

YS: Yes, in material and thematic terms. All my works are types of readymades. Even the taxidermied animals – I did not create them. Early on I studied with Israel Herschberg, and I still flirt with realism all the time. Taxidermy is the ultimate realism. So is 3D printing. When I began to work on my series of hybrid animals I had absolutely no intention to sculpt them myself. I went to a toy store, bought a plastic lion and lioness, cut them up, glued them together and created the image I wanted. Then I had this prototype made into a wax mold and then produced as a heavy bronze sculpture that can practically last forever. The bronze cast puts this ideal form – a lion-lioness – into the fold of art history. But personal style is a cliché I have no interest in. I would prefer my work be perceived not by its traces but by its modus operandi.

← Forests Adrift, Forests of WarIntroduction →