Against Gravity
Yuval Shaul appears twice in the preparatory photograph Self-Portrait with Myself (2005), doubled or, perhaps, split. One Yuval Shaul supports the other, like two spent soldiers at the end of a course, or even after battle, the one injured, the other saving him, holding him up in an act of heroism and brotherhood. The black jeans and tight black t-shirt are the uniform of the urban commando fighter, a shoulder-tag in the male army. In fact, the photograph can be seen as a self-portrait of a split man: strong and weak, supporting and held, surviving and exhausted. Perhaps it’s the same as when, wasted and groggy at the end of a long night you need to get home and at least maintain the appearance of self-control. Perhaps, in a sense, it is like this all the time: all of us, not just Yuval Shaul, are partly exhausted, downcast, seeking to give in to gravity. A young man can ignore his depleted side; he can overcome, defeat or tame it. For the older man “overcoming” is no longer a simple mission. He is very much aware of the energy it takes to sustain adulthood and manhood.
As we allow ourselves into Shaul’s split self-portrait, the emotional weight moves from its heroic aspect to its gentleness and compassion. The photograph does not depict a rift between foes but the doubling of an intimate couple: arm embraces waist, body touches body. Not only are the two undivided, they are joined. The closer we look at Shaul’s work the more we realize that at its heart is a gentle code of intimacy and compassion, and not male-heroic themes that seem to stand out at first glance.
* * *
For many years now Shaul’s work conveys an ongoing dialogue between young and old, male and female. Although they touch on gender discourse, these dialogues are neither sociologic nor political. Shaul formulates an “old-new” identity that combines “genetic,” essential masculinity with socially constructed masculinity. The emphasis in the works is the internal, emotional experience of the discourse and not its social aspects. His feminine and masculine, young and old, are internal voices, mental personas that speak through the works.
As is usually the case with binary division, they are imprecise. The works have a primordial aspect in the figure of the hardened hunter, and an urban, casual aspect with a modern “look.” Just as supporter and upheld are close to each other, so too are the human and the animalistic. Hunter and hunted are not rivals. The works address violence without being violent. They are sexy without trading in sex. At times the sexiness is icy cold and fascist, at times the works are downright arousing. Especially the bronze sculptures of the hybrid animals: a cow and a bull; a doe and a deer; a male and female whose bodies seep into each other with such complete totality the penetration is a symmetric physical merging that leaves the male no advantage over the female. These sculptures of copulating animals can be likened to household gods in a pagan rite devoted to the god of orgasms.
Whereas the bronze copulating animals belong to a rite to Eros, it is Thanatos to whom Shaul turns in other works: the animal hides and furs are the stuff of death.
Three life-size cutout figures made of horsehide appear in No Justice, Just Us! (2006): Yuval and his two sons. The son on the right is taller than his father; the other son is still a child. Both youngsters hold weapons. One holds a spear, the other a knife. The young warriors have long hair and for a moment can be mistaken for slim girls. The soft-muscular body language of the male group is similar.
What is the father’s place? Where is the adult in this order?
The words “just us” belong to the father: the bloodline, the covenant of the seed. The intergenerational dialogue is not one of conflict but of connection and acceptance; acceptance that does not erase differences. Intergenerational harmony is what comes to the fore first; later, also a sense of uneasiness. The boys look toward the father, their gazes unite the group. The father, however, is looking forward, outward – whether to the future, at the viewer, or inward. He possesses self-awareness both sons lack. His is an inward gaze that also looks out. The coarse horsehide from which the figures are cut heightens the sense of uneasiness and edginess. The sons’ fur is light and vivid, as if the form has yet to crystalize. The father’s is dark, unified and obscure. Yet what exactly is in the connection between the figures and the peeled skin? Are we with the hunter or with the hunted animal? Where are we in the food chain running between predator and prey? The older man is he who can no longer maintain his innate hunter identity, yet he is not ready to let go and give up. He is also looking at the vicious battle for survival and refusing to see it in terms of justice, of good and bad. Thus “just us” is not only “us the family” but also perhaps “us humans”: not rules of justice run matters but biological and evolutionary rules, those of skin, blood and seed.
In the decade between 1856 and 1866 Gustave Courbet painted around thirty scenes with deer. The deer might appear alone, in a family group, wrestling another deer or being hunted, bleeding and dying. Courbet’s deer is a king of sorts, but one who has no peace. Even the rattle sounds of his final breaths are muffled by barking dogs, galloping horses and shouting hunters.
A painting from 1866 shows a group of hunting dogs surrounding the defeated deer at the heart of the snowy landscape. The deer’s neck turns up toward the cold air, his mouth open in a last cry as his soul is ejected in the warm vapor. The weight of his huge antlers pulls him down. Courbet, too, recognized the force of gravitation. The deer, horse, dogs and hunters are all covered in furs that protect them against the cold and the snow. The dotted-stained coat of the horse, as also the dogs’ hair recall, somewhat alarmingly, the hides Shaul uses for his cutout figures. The fur and hide contain the warmness and attractiveness of an animal, of life. They also harbor death. Death is present in a very concrete way, in the raw materials, the peeling, drying and cutting; in the enticement to touch.
Images of naval destroyers with antlers first appeared in works from Shaul’s series Il nuovo mondo (2004-2009). These modern steel destroyers merge with Viking, pagan, and mythological vessels. Do the antlers belong to the ship, or are they the signs of the looted of the enemy? Are these destroyers leaving for battle or returning from one? Is it a war campaign or a funerary voyage? The antlers project regality and nobility. The deer is not a lion, eagle or a shark. He is a king, but not a predator king. He is not a hunter but prey, an herbivore, a bleeding victim. His awesome antlers serve to fight other males and seduce females (size counts!), not for hunting and killing. The ship is a mighty destroyer ready for battle, but far from weapons of destruction, its antlers are a dark totem. Nevertheless, even if the journey is a funeral, the back stands proud. The antlers chart an upright torso, a rack of ribs encasing an elegant, monumental back. Even in images that have the antler-crowned war machine collapsing, exploding and sinking, the antlers remain proud as they are engulfed in fire and smoke, in commotion and blood, and finally in the silence of the ocean bed.
Fighter aircraft, submarines and sunken ships lie serenely in the darkness of the deep ocean graveyard. With no one to buttress the falling body, gravity does its work. The weapons of mass destruction lie softly on the seabed like cold cadavers, or embryos in the womb. Death and fertility merge, as do the cool and the warm, the solid and the fluid. Beginning and end meet, as if completing a cycle of life.