Violence and Compassion
Although they hear it, men do not speak their mother tongue. Social demands and rules of discourse form a male identity that silences men and subjects them to a distorted language. Masculinity, therefore, has no words; the words it employs are foreign to it. The mute and ignored gender is denied self-awareness, seeing that it develops on a linguistic foundation. A masculine language can develop only away from rigid discourse: in dreams, therapy or art. These are places wherein representations and interpretations of maleness and manhood, intolerable in everyday language, can be traced. In his work, Yuval Shaul specializes in creating just this type of representation system, allowing a new understanding of male experience. Shaul’s male is positioned at a crossroads. One way offers a primal, pre-language, pre-culture instinctive existence that has no need for language. The other is an intentional, post-cultural operative existence, a necessary product of the social and linguistic order. Whereas in the first mode man acts genetically and primordially, in the second he fulfils his role in a preformed social construct. These positions coexist and men are required to comply with both.
The life and death of the soldier, a man set out to kill and be killed, provides a clear demonstration of this duality. Like other men, the soldier possesses no language of his own. He is constituted as a physiological being of raucous and reflexive violence, but also as someone who must adhere to the structure of purposeful functionality. During his military training, as he toughens, he feels within himself some sense of affinity with an ancient, primordial dictate that is demanded of him. On his return from battle he is welcomed by a society that has already prepared his status. If, on the other hand, he refuses to fight he will be punished automatically. Either way, seeing as he has no language for expressing his experience, we cannot understand it. The alexithymia – difficulty describing emotional responses – is second nature. If he is injured or dies, his suffering will be translated into themes of bravery and sanctity. His death scream silenced by the blast of trumpets, the newsreader’s voice or the documentary film made in his memory. Whenever we see a soldier, alive or dead, we sense the transmutation of meaning that removes us further from his personal experience, all the while obliterating it.
Shaul’s works stand in the speechless space between the instinctive and the functional. When, in Il nuovo mondo (2009), he shows the ultimate military warship – a naval destroyer – he adds a pair of deer antlers to its upper deck, thus undermining the type of shift we have become accustomed to. The destroyer’s destructive potential is massive, as is its intentional force. Indeed, superpowers use this force to impose their world order. The soldiers onboard seem heroic, tough and highly functional. Here, above the metal structure suddenly rises a pair of antlers: beautiful and regal, enticing and belligerent, yet also very exposed. In its natural habitat the deer carries his antlers proudly. They provide clear indication of his health and status and he uses them to wrestle his enemies. Yet despite his provocative bearing and mighty appearance he is, of course, not a predator but a hunted animal, hence vulnerable.
Crossbreeding reappears: a military submarine and a shark merge in one work; a submarine and a whale are joined in another. They are the markers of male susceptibility. Weakness comes alongside the demonstration of megalomaniac power. While seeming threatening, the deer antlers also indicate limitations. The shark is dangerous but also a hunted and endangered animal. The whale is massive but can be beached and killed by the flow of currents. Likewise, a direct strike at the center of a ship or a submarine can bring to their utter devastation, sending them to the depths of the sea. The thousands of men on them, who operate this vast destructive power like an efficient ant colony, sail on what might become their graveyard. One good blow in the stomach of masculinity is all it will take for them, and all this manifestation of manhood, to be swallowed in the large, silent womb of the ocean.
Shaul’s works fuse the impulsive bases of masculinity with the performative ones imposed by social constructs. He does so in a way that exposes the hidden, repressed, deflected sense of masculine existence. When viewing the antlered destroyer or the whale submarine we might, for a moment, feel overwhelmed by the power, the violence and the sophisticated mechanics. Yet we might also, in parallel, feel something else, something unfamiliar: boundless vulnerability that leads to compassion. Shaul toys with these meanings in a way that offers recognition of the familiar. He also reverses this process: one of his works shows a melancholy Jesus who bears not a cross, but a shotgun.
Shaul’s work can be viewed through notions developed by Gilles Deleuze and Félix Guattari about a distinct literary category they called “minor literature”; literature written from the liminal position of migrants or foreigners such as Franz Kafka, the object of their study. The minor author speaks the local language and yet is not under the dictates of the place. As a result, the migrant is not under any obligation to obey the social rules and can resist them. Thus he has a relative amount of freedom from repression which in turn allows him to oppose the social order and to create a different language. Deleuze and Guattari point to an act of deterritorialization – in this case the literature a minor writes in a major language, an act they consider revolutionary. Shaul places the male in his seemingly natural place: the battle field and war machine. Yet he performs an extreme dialectic defamiliarization when an apparently powerful representation is used to express weakness. The deterritorialization of masculine obedience frees many of its minor hidden meanings.
Interestingly, Shaul and Kafka also share an attraction to hybrid identities. In Kafka’s case these are usually animals, such as a cockroach or a monkey that are given human characteristics allowing them to describe the modern predicament. Shaul’s hybrids merge animal and machine and serve to express his universal human male. Since the beginning of time, when prehistoric man fashioned a stone, his act was both instinctive and technological. Men formed and advanced tools and technology, for the most part with little consideration to the fact that every advancing vehicle is also a restricting one. Every killing machine can also be used for suicide. The male was also a nomad and conqueror: humans emerged at the dawn of humanity in Africa, and Shaul shows a map of the continent made of cowhide, that is being led by a deer. Everything smells of primeval, gushing masculinity. However, the vulnerability is present. The destruction man carries with him is present, and men who will be sacrificed along the way like hunted deer, are present too. This sacrificing recurs in the works of the taxidermied animals that have crushed into walls and floors, lost their heads, leaving only their rear parts exposed. The male that comes forth in these works is one convinced of his power, whose sacrificial role is concealed from him.
Thus Shaul rescues meanings that are usually obstructed by the repressive language. He presents a pre-macho and non-patriarchal liberated form of self-representation. His work offers an ethics beyond aesthetics freeing art from its commitment to the establishment. His is an ethical project as it creates a language for men, who are used to being in a state in which they are deprived of one language and oppressed by another.
Shaul’s eyes show us the language-less man who is trapped between instincts and mechanics; threatening, yet lost. Similarly to the taxidermied animals with their heads stuck in walls, he too is suspended, crushed. There is, however, the question of the private man, his whereabouts, and his existential and emotional state. Clues can be found, perhaps, in Self-Portrait with Myself (2005). Here the artist shows himself. Gone are the animals and hybrids. We see the artist, upfront, in jeans and t-shirt, simple, exposed, supporting his own duplicate self. And the reason he is there to hold himself up is that as a man he has no one other than himself. He functions and collapses, always in solitude. In the absence of language there is no communication and no real place for the other. Moreover, if he were to open his mouth and voice his pain the transformative machine would crank into action and translate his anguish into grievance, difficulty, resistance. This lack of understanding leaves him with either instinct or function, choices that are exhausting and lonely. In the words of Chilean poet Pablo Neruda: “It so happens I am sick of being a man.”
Shaul makes us wonder about the man by confronting us with a new interpretation of manhood. He forces us to look at war, at man’s ability to annihilate, and at the toll it takes. We cannot be satisfied with glorifying males and we cannot turn our gaze from their fragile and complex state. We feel compassion, even in face of the violence. Shaul conveys this message most precisely with knives he made whose blades are formed from the word “compassion.” Ultimately, we harbor compassion toward violence; and this conclusion, however conflicting, confusing, annoying, subversive and precise it is, is what it is.